Gratitude gets a lot of love these days, especially around Thanksgiving. And for good reason — it can improve your mood, lower stress and even boost your health. But here’s the thing: gratitude isn’t always good. Sometimes, it can go too far. That’s when it turns into something called toxic gratitude. It’s when being thankful starts to hurt you instead of helping you.
Let’s break it down.
The double-edged sword of gratitude
Gratitude can be wonderful. It helps you appreciate the good things in life, big and small. But when you feel like you must be grateful all the time, things can get messy. Constantly forcing yourself to focus on the positive can lead you to ignore real problems or suppress emotions you need to face.
Four things you don’t need to be grateful for
Let me say it again: Gratitude can be powerful, but it’s not a blanket excuse to overlook everything wrong in your life. Here are four key areas where it’s perfectly okay to hit the brakes on gratitude. Let’s dig deeper into why these things don’t deserve your constant thankfulness.
You’ve probably heard the saying, “Be thankful for what you have.” It’s a nice idea, but it shouldn’t keep you stuck in a rut. Gratitude doesn’t mean you must settle for less than you deserve or stop striving for more.
Imagine you’re in a job that pays the bills but drains your energy. Should you be grateful to have a job? Sure — but that doesn’t mean you must stay in a role that leaves you feeling unfulfilled. The same goes for relationships, personal growth and even hobbies. Gratitude should give you a foundation of appreciation, not a ceiling that limits your potential.
Wanting to improve your life doesn’t make you ungrateful. It means you care enough about yourself to seek better. Celebrate what’s good while also dreaming bigger. Growth and gratitude can go hand in hand.
“Family is everything.” It’s a phrase that gets thrown around a lot, but let’s be real: not all family relationships are healthy. Being related to someone doesn’t give them a free pass to disrespect you, cross your boundaries, or mistreat you. And you don’t have to feel grateful for a connection that causes more harm than good.
For example, maybe you have a family member who constantly criticizes your choices or belittles your feelings. Gratitude in this situation might sound like, “Well, at least I have family, so I shouldn’t complain.” But that’s toxic gratitude talking. Genuine gratitude means appreciating the people who truly support you — not forcing yourself to tolerate bad behavior just because of shared DNA.
Setting boundaries doesn’t mean you don’t love your family. It just means you love yourself, too. Be grateful for the healthy relationships in your life, but don’t feel obligated to accept toxicity in the name of family.
Let’s talk about trauma. When bad things happen, there’s often pressure to find the “silver lining.” People might say things like, “Everything happens for a reason,” or “This will make you stronger in the end.” While those sentiments can be well-meaning, they’re never helpful — and rarely, if ever, true.
Trauma is hard. It’s messy, painful and often life changing. You don’t have to be grateful for the terrible things you’ve experienced. Sure, you might grow as a person or learn something valuable down the road, but that doesn’t mean you have to wrap your pain in a bow and call it a gift.
For example, if you’ve gone through a tough breakup, lost a loved one, or faced a major health crisis, it’s okay to say, “This was awful, and I wish it didn’t happen.” Healing takes time, and forcing gratitude can delay that process. Instead of trying to be thankful for the experience, focus on honoring your feelings and giving yourself the space to heal.
Gratitude lists are often recommended as a way to stay positive. You write down three to five things you’re thankful for every day — your morning coffee, your cozy bed, a sunny day. It’s a great practice in theory, but here’s the problem: if you only focus on gratitude, you might overlook areas in your life that need attention.
For instance, if you’re constantly grateful for “having a job,” you might not acknowledge that your workload is overwhelming or that your boss doesn’t respect your time. Or if you’re grateful for “having a partner,” you might ignore the fact that your relationship lacks honest communication. Gratitude lists can sometimes turn into a tool for avoiding tough truths.
What healthy gratitude looks like
So, what’s the right way to practice gratitude? It’s all about balance. You can be thankful and want things to get better. You can appreciate what you have and set boundaries to protect your peace. Gratitude doesn’t have to mean ignoring your pain or staying stuck.
Here are a few tips to keep gratitude healthy:
Be honest with yourself: It’s okay to admit when something isn’t working. Gratitude doesn’t mean you have to like everything about your life.
Set Boundaries: Being thankful for people or situations doesn’t mean you have to tolerate bad behavior.
Honor your feelings: Feeling sad, angry or frustrated doesn’t make you ungrateful. It makes you human.
Keep it balanced: Gratitude is just one tool in your toolbox. Use it alongside self-awareness, self-respect and a willingness to grow.
Remember, two truths can exist at the same time. You can be grateful for what you have and still want more. You can appreciate someone in your life and still call out their bad behavior. Gratitude is meant to help you, not hold you back.
In the end, gratitude should feel good
Gratitude is a powerful thing, but only when it’s used the right way. Don’t let it pressure you into ignoring your needs or accepting less than you deserve. Instead, use it to boost your happiness while also staying true to yourself.
Being thankful is great but remember this: you don’t have to be grateful for everything. Focus on what truly feeds and nourishes your soul and makes you feel good and let go of the rest. You’ll be much happier for it.
micky@hcnews.com